HE’S WATCHING YOU

Wanted poster for an individual called 'The Pill' with a black and white illustration of a person wearing a hoodie and a some kind of homemade mask.

Some people call him a rumor. Others say he’s just a mask someone wore once and never again. But if you’ve read through these names, you’ve seen the dates, the gaps, and a pattern of violence that has gone unchecked for years.

Dubbed the Pill by locals, the saying goes “If you’re a child out after dark in Page Hollow then he’ll be your medicine.” Witnesses describe him as a masked man in a long red coat. Often sighted from a distance standing still, often watching for potential victims.

However, police reports call these many cases unrelated. Whether accidents, suicides or runaways. These tragedies are often senseless, leaving authorities with no clear motive. While sightings have remained rare, the same detail keeps coming back, whispered like a warning: “He’s always watching.”

This site exists because these victims matter. Because legends don’t form out of nothing. And because if the Pill is real, and if he’s still out there, then pretending he isn’t won’t keep anyone safe.

Missing Persons Report

WHO IS THE PILL?

SIGHTINGS OF THE PILL

MISSING PERSONS

We are seeking any information on the whereabouts of the missing persons below. If you have seen one of the persons pictures, or have information pertaining to their whereabouts, please call 855-550-PILL (7455)

A smiling man with short curly hair wearing a plaid shirt sitting next to a person with glasses and a hat, engaged in an activity together.

Andy Claymore

Andy, a father and husband was last seen in Page Hollow, Michigan. His car was found on the side of the road after striking a telephone pole, remains were found at the scene but they have not been identified.

DOB: 03/20/1973 SEX: MALE

Two young women smiling outdoors, one with a yellow flower in her hair.

Adria Reed

A freshman who explored abandoned houses with friends and posted the photos. Adria was last reported to be at a boarded-up home she had never posted about. The address does not appear on any city map.

DOB: 06/13/2004 SEX: FEMALE

A young man with dark hair making a playful gesture with his fingers, wearing a blue letterman jacket with a yellow 'EH' patch, sitting indoors with others around, near a window with a parking lot outside visible.

Daniel Cavalli

His last known whereabouts were the grounds of Page Hollow High School in Page Hollow, MI. Star athlete and prom king, he was last seen wearing his varsity jacket and jeans.

DOB: 08/02/2006 SEX: MALE

A young boy playing a large bass saxophone in a room with a curtain background and a nature scene mural or backdrop. The boy has short hair and is wearing a long-sleeved shirt and pants.

The youngest victim. Tim never came home from his walk to the corner store. His voicemail was received hours later: thirty seconds of breathing, followed by a voice whispering his name.

DOB: 9/25/70 SEX: MALE

Tim Motzer

A young woman with long wavy hair smiling, wearing a t-shirt with the word 'MICE' and a choker necklace, standing in front of lockers in a school or gym locker room.

Jessica Lafferty

She was last seen at the Hideaway Motel in Page Hollow, Michigan. She was last seen wearing wearing a tank top, skirt, and neon shoes. She may have been under the influence of drugs at the time of her disappearance.

DOB: 4/25/2008 SEX: FEMALE

Person with short dark hair, wearing a green shirt, green beaded necklace, and a septum piercing, leaning against a locker in a school hallway.

Shawn Phillips

Last seen in Page Hollow, Michigan. She was last reported wearing a dark colored shirt and septum ring.

DOB: 4/25/2008 SEX: FEMALE

VIEW ALL MISSING PERSONS